Blog

Does background music help you study?

· Jason Lang

Lo-fi playlists, rain sounds, white noise, your favorite album on repeat. Almost everyone studies with something playing, and almost everyone is sure it helps. The research has a less flattering but more useful answer: it depends a lot on what's playing and on what you're doing while it plays.

The short answer

For memorizing and for reading comprehension, quiet is usually best, steady background sound comes close, instrumental music costs a little, and music with lyrics costs the most. For long, repetitive work that you'd otherwise abandon, the mood and energy music gives you can be worth that cost. The rest of this post is the why, so you can make the call for your own sessions.

The Mozart effect, briefly

In 1993, a short paper in Nature reported that students did better on a spatial reasoning task after listening to ten minutes of Mozart. The effect was small and lasted about fifteen minutes, but it turned into a decade of "make your baby smarter" CDs. Later replications mostly failed, and a 2010 meta-analysis found little left of it beyond what you'd expect from any pleasant, energizing listening.

That last part is the useful bit. Glenn Schellenberg and colleagues showed the boost had nothing to do with Mozart specifically: music that put people in a good mood and raised their alertness helped, slow or sad music didn't, and an upbeat audiobook worked as well as Mozart for people who liked it. Music can help you study by changing how you feel. It doesn't make you smarter.

Lyrics vs. instrumental: words compete with words

The clearest finding in this whole area is about speech. Since the early 1980s, experiments on the "irrelevant speech effect" have shown that people remember lists of words worse when someone is talking in the background, even when they're told to ignore it, and even when the speech is in a language they don't understand. You can't switch off the part of your brain that processes speech. It takes in whatever is playing, whether you want it to or not.

Lyrics are speech set to music, and they behave the same way. In a 2014 study by Nick Perham and Harriet Currie, students did reading comprehension tests in silence, with instrumental music, and with music that had lyrics. Lyrical music gave clearly the worst scores. Silence gave the best. A few years earlier, Perham found that it didn't matter whether people liked the music or not: both their favorite songs and songs they disliked hurt recall compared to quiet.

Later work narrowed it down further. What disrupts memory is sound that keeps changing: distinct syllables, notes jumping from one pitch to another, a beat with sudden accents. Your brain keeps tracking those changes, and that tracking competes with keeping things in order in your own head. Steady sound that doesn't change much from moment to moment disrupts far less.

White noise, rain and other steady sounds

That's why continuous sound like rain, wind, waves or white noise sits much closer to silence than music does. It has almost no changing structure to track. Its biggest practical benefit is masking: in a library, a shared flat or a café, steady sound covers the conversations around you. Those conversations are exactly the irrelevant speech that hurts concentration most, so swapping unpredictable talking for even rain is a real improvement, not just a preference.

There's also a more speculative line of research on white noise itself. Studies by Göran Söderlund and colleagues found that moderate noise helped children with attention difficulties on memory tasks, while it made no difference or slightly hurt children without them. The idea is that people who are under-aroused benefit from a bit of extra stimulation, and people who aren't don't need it. The results are mixed and the samples small, so treat it as a reason to experiment, not a rule.

Where lo-fi fits

Lo-fi became the default study soundtrack for good reasons, and they line up with the research better than most genres. It's instrumental, so no lyrics. It's slow, quiet and compressed, with few sudden changes. And it's repetitive enough to fade into the background after a few minutes. Of all the music you could put on, it's close to the least disruptive kind.

It's still music, though, with melodies and changing chords, so it's still slightly worse than quiet for the hardest memory work. Where it earns its keep is the long stretches: a hundred and fifty reviews, a pile of problem sets, an evening of notes. If it keeps you in your chair and in a decent mood for the second hour, that's worth more than a small cost to each individual card.

A practical rule of thumb

  • Learning new material or reading something hard: silence, or steady background sound if your surroundings are noisy.
  • Reviewing cards you mostly know, or long repetitive work: steady sound or quiet instrumental music like lo-fi, whichever keeps you going.
  • Anything with words in it: save music with lyrics, podcasts and videos for breaks, or for tasks that don't involve reading or remembering.
  • Keep the volume low. Loud, fast music hurt reading comprehension in experiments where the same piece at a lower volume and slower tempo didn't.
  • Do your last practice runs in quiet. Your exam will almost certainly be silent. Memory works a little better when the conditions at recall match the ones you practiced in, so the last week before an exam is a good time to turn the sound off.

How Mneme's ambient mixer does it

Mneme has an ambient mixer built in, designed around exactly this split. It has steady sounds for masking and quiet focus (rain, wind, ocean waves, underwater noise, a thunderstorm, a campfire) and livelier ones (jungle, seagulls, office murmur) for when quiet feels too quiet. Each recording is loudness-matched and loops seamlessly, so there's no audible jump that pulls your attention every few minutes.

It also has a lo-fi track, and that one isn't a playlist. The app generates it on the fly from chord progressions and samples, so it keeps going for as long as your session does without a song ever ending, starting over or switching to a track with vocals. Every source has its own volume slider, so you can layer quiet lo-fi over rain, save a mix as a preset, or add your own sound files. A sleep timer can stop the mix when your Pomodoro focus block ends. The mixer is part of the free version.

Get 33% off Mneme Pro at launch

Keep reading